|
Post by julesd68 on Jul 15, 2014 20:01:48 GMT
My son was watching the classic Bugs Bunny cartoon last night where he's trying to play Liszt's legendary 'Hungarian Rhapsody' no 2 - genius … I don't have a recording of this epic and was inspired to have a trawl through YouTube for some interesting versions. And what an amazing contrast I found! The three following performances all show exactly what goes into an 'interpretation' of a great work - just see how three great pianists differ entirely in their approach to this work, and the stamp they put on it … Do have a listen and please vote with your favourite version! First of all, we have possibly the world's most famous pianist, Lang Lang, who positively explodes into some flamboyant keyboard pyrotechnics … For me, this version is a bit like champagne - an effervescent and heady quick thrill that sadly soon fades from the memory … And now, here's how it should be done in my humble opinion - sorry no video, only audio for these next two! Firstly, the boy Horowitz, recorded in 1953 … This version is full bodied, muscular and powerful like a Grand Cru Classe Pauillac. Played with total authority and a great sense of drama. And finally, renowned as a master interpreter of Liszt - Alfred Brendel. His version is more like a fine Burgundy - silken, nuanced and refined par excellence …
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 15, 2014 20:25:55 GMT
Right for me, although I couldn't get the Horowitz to work on your link, got it direct though.
I have never enjoyed the actor pianists, not all show as they are clearly brilliant but I never enjoy the look at me stuff. Brendel is good but I find him just a little dull, so its Horowitz for me.
|
|
|
Post by Andrei on Jul 15, 2014 20:52:11 GMT
Lang Lang for me. I generally agree about flouncing around being kitsch but I make an exception for a piece like this that is rather extravagant.
|
|
|
Post by kember on Jul 15, 2014 21:03:17 GMT
Julian,
I'll vote Horowitz but then I'm a claret kind of chap! I, too, find Brendel mildly narcoleptic too often.
P
|
|
|
Post by jandl100 on Jul 15, 2014 21:12:39 GMT
I love Lang Lang's pyrotechnics. And given the setting I think he can be forgiven for going a bit over the top. I wouldn't want it as my only version, though. I enjoyed the Horowitz as well, but Brendel I find uninvolved and uninvolving.
|
|
|
Post by MartinT on Jul 16, 2014 7:38:31 GMT
It's the Brendel for me, to my surprise. Measured, but he gets more music from it than the obvious pyrotechnics of Lang Lang.
|
|
|
Post by julesd68 on Jul 16, 2014 8:42:32 GMT
Thanks for taking the time to listen chaps!
I find it very interesting to see what people find appealing and why ... As ever, in music and hi-fi, a great divergence of opinion. I haven't quite made my mind up yet which one I would keep for a desert island disc so will re-listen ...
More votes please!
|
|
|
Post by MikeMusic on Jul 18, 2014 12:59:38 GMT
Bizarre There's me a classical know nothing and it has to be Brendel. Thanks Jules. Learning experience. I almost didn't do it.
Piano, slightly different note/s I like Bruce Hornsby a lot. He does different versions of his own toons and very good and interesting they are too. Think there must be a great deal of humour as he starts some of them off 'broken/wrong' and then transforms them into the recognisable track. Don't be put off by his pop popularity. He is damned good
|
|
|
Post by julesd68 on Jul 18, 2014 14:04:20 GMT
Brilliant, thank you Mike! The interpretations are so markedly different, it's just about using your ears, not about what you know ... The rest is down to personal preference.
|
|
|
Post by MikeMusic on Jul 18, 2014 14:50:40 GMT
You can practice on me again
|
|