|
Post by puffin on Feb 20, 2017 19:42:38 GMT
Funny how things go in three's. With "the wife" having taken to her sick bed a couple of weeks ago and in between my impersonating Basil Fawlty and chasing around like a lunatic catering for her every need, I found time to tinker with some abandoned DIY stuff that had gone a bit funny sometime ago.
One of these Pre's was a Lightspeed using LDRs (Light Dependant Resistors). I am probably teaching to the perverted so apologies if I appear be sucking eggs.
If anyone was a member of Diyaudio about 8 years ago there started a looooooong thread urging everyone to build one of these as they were "revolutionary", the pot is used as a voltage source and there are no moving parts in the signal chain. The parts count was very low so I built a couple for myself and some for friends. The one in front of me last week was a "proper" offering, by "proper" I mean it was built with a PCB not P2P and has matched LDRs. However, it didn't sound right. A bit of tinkering and it didn't take much to bring it on song.
An LDR Pre is a passive unit, but IMO it sounds so much more like an active pre. If you haven't tried one, you ought to give one a go. if you can use a soldering iron and follow a simple schematic, you can build one for about £20.
|
|
|
Post by kettlechips on Feb 20, 2017 22:01:53 GMT
I'm currently running a Stereo Coffee LDR pre amp in my main system, in front of a valve power amp, and it's a great combination. I agree that LDR pre's do seem to have more welly than a true passive pre.
|
|
|
Post by John on Feb 21, 2017 5:41:50 GMT
Think James (sovergin) uses one
|
|
|
Post by dsjr on Feb 21, 2017 9:19:13 GMT
Cadmium - cough - legal issues with cadmium in the UK - cough - short life and difficult to calibrate as they drift apparently - cough.....
What I really wanted to ask is how these can possibly be better than a proper attenuator - shunt with only one resistor in series and a selection of shunt values across the load to adjust 'volume.' The LDR types I've seen are hideously complex for what is basically a variable 'L' pad..
Maybe I'm missing something..
|
|
|
Post by puffin on Feb 21, 2017 9:27:26 GMT
I have always been philosophical about the timing of my demise so should I be bothered about the risk? I was under the impression that these were simple, not complex?
|
|
|
Post by dsjr on Feb 21, 2017 9:34:19 GMT
You can't get simpler than a high quality attenuator. LDR's need power, remote electronics with some kind of control to maintain channel matching and so on and one or two I've seen look more complex than a proper active preamp.. Just my vibe obviously...
|
|
|
Post by Sovereign on Feb 21, 2017 21:14:57 GMT
Think James (sovergin) uses one Yes mate, I also use a Stereo Coffee LDR. Although mine is a bit different as Chris used it as a 'lab' type unit to try some new ideas on, as I was very familiar with passives and his normal LDR's, so he wanted to see what I thought. I found the moded one I received back from him to be different and better than the standard. Ive tried all sorts of passives using just attenuators, and I prefere the stereo coffee quite a bit more, so I have stuck with it.
|
|